O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill "Your Friendly Neighborhood Gathering Place"
O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill"Your Friendly Neighborhood Gathering Place"

O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill: We strive for perfection

Whether for a late lunch, dinner or a round of drinks in the evening, visiting O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill is always an extraordinary experience. Relax with family or friends over a premium cocktail, or indulge in one of the world-class bottled beers for which O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill is famous. Friendly service is a given.


The team at O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill looks forward to welcoming you!

Food Menu

To us, food is synonymous with freshness and quality served in a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. We are your quintessential pub and grill with delicious food that is served from open to close. O'Toole's is always ready to serve you!

Our menu is constantly evolving to offer you the freshest seasonal fare.

 Here you'll find a sampling of what we have to offer.

Appetizers & Such

Mozzarella Sticks

Battered & Deep Fried Mozzarella Served with Marinara Sauce


Jalapeno Poppers

Fiesta Dipping Sauce


Nacho Bites

Three Cheese & Bean, Served with Fiesta Dipping Sauce


Onion Rings Basket

Basket Of Battered & Deep Fried Onions Rings


French Fries Basket

Deep Fried & Served with Cheese Sauce


Mushroom Basket

Crispy Battered Mushrooms, Served with Ranch Dressing

Garlic Cheesy Bread
Toasted & Served with Warm Marinara Sauce




Best Wings on the Westside!

Wings Sold with Baby Carrots & a Choice of Blue Cheese or Ranch Dressing


Bone In (Fresh Jumbo Wings)



6 Piece Order $7.95
12 Piece Order $14.95
18 Piece Order $21.95
Boneless (Fresh & Juicy)

Wing Sauces

  • BBQ, Mild, Hot, Extra Hot, Cajun
  • Carolina Gold, Teriyaki & Garlic Parmesan
  • Extra Sauce or Wet
  • Cheese Sauce








Sandwich Baskets

Tavern Burger

1/4 lb. Hamburger, Topped with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, and Pickle, Served on a Kaiser Bun




All Beef Hot Dog

Roasted 1/4lb. Beef Frank,

Served on a Steak Bun


BBQ Pork Sandwich

Pulled Pork Slowly Roasted in Baby's Rays BBQ Sauce, Served on a Kaiser Bun

All Sandwich Baskets Served
with French Fries, and Coleslaw 
Add $1.25 For Choice Of Cheese
** Sanwiches Unavailable After 11pm

Baskets & Entrées

Fish Basket

Breaded with Tattar Sauce

3 Piece

2 Piece








Boneless Wing Basket
Lightly Breaded & Tossed in a Choice of Sauce or Dry Rub

*See Wings For Choice of Sauce

or Dry Rub


Shrimp Basket

Beer battered Rock Shrimp with Cocktail Sauce


All Baskets Served

with Fries, and Coleslaw



12" Cheese

  • Extra Toppings
  • Loaded






14" Cheese

  • Extra Toppings
  • Loaded




Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Onions, Tomatoes,

Banana Peppers, Green Peppers & Mushrooms


*Menu and prices are subject to change without notice.


** Notice: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness.

Contact Us



O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill

4796 West Broad Street

Columbus, OH 43228

Phone 614-878-6461




Or use our contact form.


Business Hours

Bar Hours

2pm - 2am Weekdays

12pm - 2am Weekends


Kitchen Hours

2pm - 1am Weekdays

12pm - 1am Weekends

* Hours Subject To Change *





What's New

New website

Looking for entertainment? Visit us online to find out what's on tap.


This month


Happy hour  Open-6pm
every day!

All cocktails are specially priced.
* Some drinks are excluded


O'Toole's Carryout Menu
In a hurry, need a menu on the fly?
As an alternative to browsing our menu on this website, click here to download a complete copy.
Carryout menu 1.23.24.pdf
Adobe Acrobat document [716.7 KB]

Note: You will need Adobe(r) Reader(r) to view PDF files. If you do not have it, you can download it for free.

Website and Design

Like our new web presence,

click here for more information.

Print | Sitemap
© O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill

This website was created using IONOS MyWebsite.